VH
Journal

What a bad week tells you about a senior hire

The specific failure under pressure reveals more than the resume or the reference.

BoardroomCultureCareer·3 min read

I ask new senior hires about their last bad week because I need to see how they inhabit difficulty. Not difficulty in the abstract. A specific week. A moment when something they were responsible for did not go as planned. The question is simple. The answer is where the real information lives.

Most people prepare for interviews by rehearsing their wins. They shape a narrative around growth, learning, resilience. These are not lies. But they are curated. The bad week question disrupts the curation. It asks for the unvarnished account of a time when preparation was not enough. Did they blame the market, the team, the predecessor. Or did they sit with what they could have done differently.

What I listen for is not contrition. Contrition is cheap. What I listen for is whether they can hold two thoughts at once. The week was bad because of factors beyond their control, yes. And also because they missed something they should have seen. The ability to stay in that tension, to resist the pull toward pure self-exoneration, tells me something about their internal compass. It tells me they will not break the firm in a difficult quarter.

A senior hire who starts by contextualising the failure is someone I want on the team. 'The market moved three percent overnight. We were hedged for one and a half.' That is the opening. Then the specifics. 'I should have modelled for a scenario that seemed unlikely at the time.' Or 'I trusted a colleague's assessment when I had reason to doubt it.' The good candidate does not flinch from the personal accountability that sits inside the structural explanation.

I also listen for what they do next. Did they call the CFO, or did they wait for the CFO to call them. Did they loop in the risk function before they had to. Did they document what happened while it was still happening, or after they had decided what story to tell. These are the micro-decisions that matter. They tell me whether someone operates with the discipline that a regulated environment demands, or whether they treat compliance as something that begins when the regulator knocks on the door.

The bad week question also reveals something about intellectual honesty. I have interviewed candidates who reframed a clear operational failure as a learning opportunity without acknowledging the cost to the business. They said the right words. They sounded reflective. But they had not sat with the weight of what happened. By contrast, a candidate who says 'We lost a client. That was on me. I have thought about it every quarter since' is showing me something different. That is the person who understands that some failures do not get processed into wisdom. Some just sit with you.

In my experience, the quality of a senior hire has less to do with whether they have ever failed than with how they think about the failure after the fact. Everyone in this work has a bad week. The question is whether they are still learning from it three years on, or whether they have already moved the story into 'that was then'. I need people who stay with the hard thing. That is how boards stay functional. That is how compliance becomes real.

Volha Havorchanka

Volha Havorchanka

Chief of Strategy & Operations, ST Holdings Ltd